Challenges to Open Access Publishing
About This Session
Predatory Publishers are Spoiling Open Access
Jeffrey Beal. 10:15 - 10:45 am
Predatory publishers are hurting science communication and tarnishing the open access movement by unethically exploiting the gold open-access model for their own profit. The number of predatory publishers and predatory standalone journals is greatly increasing, as is author misconduct -- such as plagiarism -- which these publishers enable and facilitate. The presence of predatory publishers has many implications for academic librarians, who need to be more realistic and less idealistic about open access publishing. To better serve their patrons, librarians need to repurpose the concept of readers' advisory for the 21st century, bringing the skill of scholarly publishing literacy to their campuses.
SAGE Open: A case study of a for-profit publisher’s foray into Gold OA for the humanities and social sciences
Jim Gilden. 10:45 - 11:15 am
Author pays models of OA publishing have gained wide acceptance in STM, especially medicine. But social scientists and humanities scholars have different needs and understanding of OA publishing.
Launched in 2010, SAGE Open is a multidisciplinary peer reviewed Gold OA journal for social scientists and humanities scholars. Based on the PLOS One model, it has been by many measures a success. But it has also proved a challenge for editorial, marketing, publishing and back office operations. A look at some of what we’ve learned and are still learning.
Open Access and Its Enemies
J. Britt Holbrook. 11:15 - 11:45 am
I treat Open Access as a ‘sociotechnical imaginary’ – that is, as an attempt to enlist technology to co-produce a future for scholarly communication that we would like to see realized. But who are ‘we’ and what is the future ‘we’ envision? Speaking as someone engaged in scholarly communication, but also as someone whose scholarly communication is reflexive, I offer an account of who ‘we’ are and what it means for ‘us’ to communicate. I also offer an outline of who ‘they’ – the enemies of Open Access – are (HINT: they include some of us).
Keywords: Open Access; scholar; communication; publisher; libraries; policy; neoliberalism
View the Presentation
- Scholarly Initiatives Librarian, Auraria Library, University of Colorado Denver
Jeffrey Beall is the Scholarly Initiatives Librarian at Auraria Library, University of Colorado Denver. Jeffrey is the author of the website called Scholarly Open Access, a blog that tracks and critically analyzes questionable, open-access publishers and journals.More Info.
- Editor, SAGE Open Sales at SAGE Publications
Jim Gilden is the Editor for SAGE Open Sales at SAGE Publications. Jim has worked in publishing for more than 20 years. He first started at SAGE in journals marketing in 1994 and has also held positions there in academic software sales and marketing.More Info.
- Assistant Director, Center for the Study of Interdisciplinarity, University of North Texas
- Assistant Professor, Department of Philosophy and Religion Studies, University of North Texas
J. Britt Holbrook is Assistant Director of the Center for the Study of Interdisciplinarity and Research Assistant Professor within the Department of Philosophy and Religion Studies at the University of North Texas. Holbrook’s work since 2005 has aimed to challenge the typical distinctions between research, teaching, and service according to which faculty members are judged.More Info.